Driver Struck 11 College Cyclists on Morning Training Ride. Two Died

The Driver

Carter County District Attorney Steve Finney said a 69-year-old man from Newland, North Carolina, identified as John Benfield, was arrested at the scene. He faces two counts of vehicular homicide by recklessness and five counts of aggravated assault by vehicle with recklessness, one charge for each cyclist killed or injured. The Tennessee Highway Patrol's investigation into the crash was still underway as of this writing, and no additional details about the driver's conduct in the moments before the collision have been made public.

Who Haylan Engdahl and Brayden Rogers Were

Both students were sophomores and members of a cycling program that had drawn serious national attention. Earlier this year, Milligan's men's cycling team won the team time trial national championship at the USA Cycling Collegiate Road Nationals in Wisconsin, a testament to how competitive and disciplined this group of athletes was. A morning training ride like the one on Wednesday would have been a routine part of that level of commitment, the kind of early-morning miles that go into building a program strong enough to win at nationals.

A Second Tragedy for the Same Program

This is not the first fatal roadway incident to strike Milligan's cycling and running programs this year. In an unrelated hit-and-run near Williamsburg, Virginia, five members of the university's track and field team were struck by a driver while training ahead of a meet; sophomore Eli Cramer, 20, died from his injuries, and several teammates were hurt. 

Two serious roadway incidents involving student-athletes from the same relatively small university, in the same year, is a pattern worth naming plainly: endurance athletes who train on public roads are exposed to a level of risk that has nothing to do with their own skill or caution, and everything to do with the drivers sharing that road with them.

Why Cyclist-Involved Crashes Carry Distinct Legal Weight

Crashes involving cyclists struck by vehicles occupy a specific and serious category in personal injury law, largely because of the enormous disparity in mass and protection between a bicycle and a car. Even at moderate speeds, a vehicle striking a cyclist can cause catastrophic injury or death, which is why states, including Tennessee, generally hold drivers to a high standard of care around cyclists lawfully using the roadway. Reckless vehicular homicide and aggravated assault by vehicle charges, as filed here, reflect a legal judgment that the driver's conduct went beyond ordinary negligence into a more serious category of culpability, though the specific facts supporting that charge haven't yet been made public.

For the injured cyclists and the families of Engdahl and Rogers, the criminal case against the driver is one track. A separate civil claim for wrongful death and personal injury does not depend on the outcome of the criminal proceedings, and the felony charges already filed will likely serve as significant supporting evidence of the driver's liability in any such claim.

Our deepest condolences go out to the families of Haylan Engdahl and Brayden Rogers, to the seven cyclists still recovering, and to the entire Milligan University community.

If you or a loved one has been injured while cycling on a public road, the independent attorneys we connect you with can help you understand your legal options and pursue full accountability from the driver responsible.

For more articles like this, visit our News Page.